Planning problems and trade-offs in production

On-time delivery, utilisation, inventory, set-up effort: why planning objectives conflict and how a weighted objective function balances them.

Written by Dominik Eibl · · updated · 3 min read

The short answer: The engine models the factors that shape real production planning: sequencing and set-ups, machines and their capabilities, staff with shifts and qualifications, material and inventory, lot sizes, deliveries, and regulatory and ESG requirements. Because these objectives conflict, they are not optimised one by one but weighed together in an individually weighted objective system.

Where conventional planning reaches its limits

Many plants plan with Excel, standard ERP functions and a great deal of experience. That works as long as the number of dependencies stays manageable. Once every factor applies at the same time, three things typically follow: high planning effort, untapped potential in utilisation and throughput, and opaque decisions that only the person who made the plan can follow.

The triangle: delivery capability, inventory, utilisation

A production partner once described planning to us as a triangle:

  • Delivery capability: delivering on time is the top priority for most companies. It often requires safety stock or highly flexible production – and both cost money.
  • Inventory: high inventory protects delivery capability but ties up capital and storage space.
  • Utilisation: well-utilised machines and staff lower unit costs. But fully loaded production lengthens lead times and responds less well to change.

The literature describes this as the scheduling and materials-planning dilemma (Erlach, 2020): small lot sizes improve on-time delivery but increase set-up effort; large lots lower unit costs but cost flexibility. There is no complete resolution – but there is a better balance.

Efficiency or robustness?

A plan that schedules every minute is efficient – and fragile. If a machine fails or material is missing, the whole sequence falters. Too many buffers, on the other hand, make the plan expensive. Robustness and efficiency are therefore not opposites but two objectives that need to be weighted deliberately. How the engine handles disruption is covered in Short-notice changes and re-planning.

The factors the engine models

Sequencing, set-up and cleaning. Set-up and cleaning times often depend on the sequence: running the same material again considerably reduces the effort. Sequencing is therefore also an economic decision.

Machines. Not every machine can process every order. Different levels of automation, maintenance windows and bottleneck machines are all taken into account.

Staff. Shift models, availability and qualifications determine who can operate which machine. Multi-machine operation is possible, but not always sensible.

Material and inventory. An order can only start once its pre-material is available or arriving in time. Inventory and materials planning feed into the plan.

Lot sizes, delivery and logistics. Lot sizes, delivery dates and logistics can be considered in the same plan rather than planned separately.

Regulatory and ESG requirements. Requirements on resource use or working conditions can also be modelled as an objective or a constraint.

Individual weighting instead of a one-size-fits-all optimum

There is no single optimal plan for every plant. A plant with expensive bottleneck machines weights utilisation differently from one with strict delivery dates. That is why the objectives are agreed and weighted together. At ams OSRAM, for example, the central trade-off was meeting delivery dates reliably and reducing backlogs while keeping machine and staff utilisation optimal.

Sources: Erlach, K. (2020). Wertstromdesign. Springer; Stockmann, C. & Winkler, H. (2020). Robustheit in Produktionssystemen aus Sicht der industriellen Praxis. BTU Cottbus-Senftenberg.

How much potential is there in your planning?

In the free potential check (45 minutes), we talk about your current planning and assess together whether and where DeepSynergy.AI Production Planning can help.

Free potential check(opens booking calendar in a new tab)